This episode examines first loves, as evident by the title. Claire and Trevor meet an old friend of Champs, a musician named Sophie (played by guest star Lisa Loeb). They wind up going on a road trip to find Sophie's first love, the one she never got over. She winds up finding love in an unexpected place. In the meantime, Claire has been ordered to medicate Trevor. Since she's become accustomed to him, she is reluctant to put him on it. Due to a misunderstanding, Trevor thinks that she is in favour of the medication, and spends a lot of time making pointed barbs in her direction. Through flashbacks, we also see Claire's first love, met at summer camp.
Psychiatrist, talking about Trevor to Claire
And how do you know he even has a sex drive?
Trevor: You ever get tired of psychoanalysing?
Claire: I was a pre-eighteen girl, Trevor, at one time. Were you?
Sophie: You're not a loser, Trevor. If you were a loser, I would have already dated
you.
Claire: I've seen him dance.
Claire: Now that you mention it, I am a bit winded.
Trevor: Let me think about it. There was a time when I had a real nice little...
Kajagoogoo - Two Shy
Susanna Hoffs - It Must Be Love
Khaleel - No Mercy
Bobby Bare Jr. - You're Ruining My Life
Lisa Loeb - Drunk and I Won't Remember and Happy Together
(both recorded specially for CUPID)
Paul Adelstein
....
Mike
Noelle Bou-Sliman
....
Tina
Sean Bradley
....
Lester
Wayne Brown (I)
....
Dr. Greeley
Daniel Bryant
....
Laurence
Kevin Michael Doyle
....
Sophie's father
Kathryn Jaeck
....
Sophie's mother
Lisa Loeb
....
Sophie
Jeff Parise
....
Nick
Hollis Resnik
Marc Vann
The episode was transcribed by the owner of Spread The Love and can be found here